Lucas Gautheron vor 3 Wochen
Ursprung
Commit
74a565e1d5

+ 0 - 1
output/etm_20_pretrained/sankey_control_control_nu_compact.pdf

@@ -1 +0,0 @@
-../../.git/annex/objects/pG/ww/MD5E-s27719--ac7fdfe9275ae3e763aa5d4496562ba7.pdf/MD5E-s27719--ac7fdfe9275ae3e763aa5d4496562ba7.pdf

+ 1 - 0
output/etm_20_pretrained/sankey_control_control_nu_compact.pdf

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+/annex/objects/MD5E-s27725--935bae98610f0a3382f4a62a9c72e79b.pdf

+ 1 - 0
output/etm_20_pretrained/sankey_control_control_nu_compact_darkmatter.pdf

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+/annex/objects/MD5E-s27431--b7966946fbc1aac88214bf5998807c73.pdf

+ 22 - 23
output/etm_20_pretrained/summary_change_disruption.tex

@@ -1,33 +1,32 @@
 \begin{table}[H]
-\centering
 \caption{Effect of each variable on (a) the change score and (b) the disruption score for each model. The reference model uses entropy as the diversity measure $D$ and the magnitude of intellectual capital as a measure of power $P$. Values indicate the mean posterior effect size and the 95\% credible interval. Significant effects are shown in bold.}
 \label{table:summary_change_disruption}
 \renewcommand{\arraystretch}{2}\fontsize{6}{7}\selectfont\begin{tabular}{lllllll}
 \toprule
 Dep. variable & \multicolumn{3}{c}{Change score ($c_a$)} & \multicolumn{3}{c}{Disruption score ($d_a$)} \\
-Model &                                Reference &                      $D=\text{Stirling}$ &                     $P=\text{Brokerage}$ &                                Reference &                      $D=\text{Stirling}$ &                     $P=\text{Brokerage}$ \\
-Predictor                                 &                                          &                                          &                                          &                                          &                                          &                                          \\
+Model & Reference & $D=\text{Stirling}$ & $P=\text{Brokerage}$ & Reference & $D=\text{Stirling}$ & $P=\text{Brokerage}$ \\
+Predictor &  &  &  &  &  &  \\
 \midrule
-\textbf{Intellectual capital (diversity)} &  $\bm{+0.28}\substack{+0.043 \\ -0.043}$ &  $\bm{+0.28}\substack{+0.041 \\ -0.041}$ &  $\bm{+0.22}\substack{+0.043 \\ -0.043}$ &    $\bm{+0.04}\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.04}$ &     $\bm{+1.2}\substack{+0.47 \\ -0.48}$ &         $+0.04\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.04}$ \\
-\textbf{Social capital (diversity)}       &    $\bm{+0.09}\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.04}$ &  $\bm{+0.07}\substack{+0.042 \\ -0.041}$ &    $\bm{+0.06}\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.04}$ &  $\bm{+0.28}\substack{+0.045 \\ -0.044}$ &    $\bm{+0.85}\substack{+0.47 \\ -0.48}$ &  $\bm{+0.22}\substack{+0.043 \\ -0.044}$ \\
-\textbf{Social capital (power)}           &  $\bm{-0.22}\substack{+0.041 \\ -0.041}$ &     $\bm{-0.2}\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.04}$ &  $\bm{-0.14}\substack{+0.044 \\ -0.044}$ &  $\bm{-0.23}\substack{+0.042 \\ -0.042}$ &   $\bm{-0.21}\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.041}$ &  $\bm{-0.14}\substack{+0.044 \\ -0.045}$ \\
-\textbf{Stable affiliation}               &   $\bm{-0.14}\substack{+0.079 \\ -0.08}$ &  $\bm{-0.14}\substack{+0.079 \\ -0.079}$ &   $\bm{-0.17}\substack{+0.079 \\ -0.08}$ &    $\bm{-0.1}\substack{+0.079 \\ -0.08}$ &  $\bm{-0.11}\substack{+0.078 \\ -0.078}$ &  $\bm{-0.13}\substack{+0.082 \\ -0.081}$ \\
-\hline Hadrons                                   &           $+0.01\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ &          $-0.11\substack{+0.17 \\ -0.2}$ &           $-0.02\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ &        $+0.003\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.02}$ &        $-0.008\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.03}$ &       $+0.0006\substack{+0.01 \\ -0.01}$ \\
-String theory \& supergravity             &     $\bm{+0.3}\substack{+0.14 \\ -0.14}$ &    $\bm{+0.39}\substack{+0.18 \\ -0.18}$ &    $\bm{+0.15}\substack{+0.13 \\ -0.13}$ &    $\bm{+0.02}\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.02}$ &    $\bm{+0.04}\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.02}$ &       $+0.004\substack{+0.01 \\ -0.008}$ \\
-Perturbative methods                      &          $+0.1\substack{+0.21 \\ -0.17}$ &           $+0.03\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.2}$ &           $+0.09\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.2}$ &         $+0.01\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.02}$ &         $+0.01\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.03}$ &        $+0.008\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.01}$ \\
-Classical fields                          &         $-0.13\substack{+0.29 \\ -0.46}$ &          $-0.1\substack{+0.34 \\ -0.44}$ &           $-0.08\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.4}$ &        $-0.009\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.05}$ &        $-0.009\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.05}$ &        $-0.003\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.03}$ \\
-Collider physics                          &    $\bm{-0.17}\substack{+0.15 \\ -0.16}$ &    $\bm{-0.35}\substack{+0.18 \\ -0.19}$ &    $\bm{-0.21}\substack{+0.15 \\ -0.15}$ &        $-0.005\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.02}$ &    $\bm{-0.02}\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.03}$ &        $-0.004\substack{+0.01 \\ -0.02}$ \\
-Dynamics                                  &           $-0.05\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.3}$ &           $-0.02\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.4}$ &         $-0.02\substack{+0.25 \\ -0.29}$ &       $+0.0006\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.03}$ &        $+0.003\substack{+0.05 \\ -0.05}$ &        $+0.001\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.02}$ \\
-Neutrinos \& flavour physics              &    $\bm{+0.24}\substack{+0.17 \\ -0.16}$ &         $+0.17\substack{+0.19 \\ -0.18}$ &    $\bm{+0.15}\substack{+0.16 \\ -0.15}$ &         $+0.02\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.02}$ &         $+0.02\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.02}$ &       $+0.006\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.009}$ \\
-Black holes                               &           $+0.05\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.1}$ &          $+0.18\substack{+0.22 \\ -0.2}$ &           $+0.02\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ &        $-0.007\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.02}$ &        $+0.008\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.02}$ &        $-0.005\substack{+0.01 \\ -0.02}$ \\
-Gauge theory \& Grand Unification         &           $-0.08\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.3}$ &            $-0.1\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.4}$ &           $-0.04\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.3}$ &        $-0.003\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.03}$ &        $-0.009\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.05}$ &        $-9e-05\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.02}$ \\
-Dark matter                               &          $-0.19\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.24}$ &    $\bm{-0.27}\substack{+0.25 \\ -0.27}$ &         $-0.16\substack{+0.19 \\ -0.24}$ &         $-0.01\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.04}$ &       $-0.02\substack{+0.027 \\ -0.043}$ &        $-0.007\substack{+0.01 \\ -0.03}$ \\
-Thermodynamics                            &           $+0.08\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.2}$ &            $+0.2\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.3}$ &           $+0.08\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.2}$ &        $+0.006\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.03}$ &         $+0.02\substack{+0.06 \\ -0.04}$ &        $+0.004\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.02}$ \\
-Cosmology                                 &           $-0.01\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.2}$ &           $+0.03\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.2}$ &           $-0.03\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.2}$ &        $-0.009\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.03}$ &        $-0.004\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.03}$ &        $-0.006\substack{+0.01 \\ -0.02}$ \\
-Electroweak sector                        &           $-0.06\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ &         $-0.16\substack{+0.17 \\ -0.18}$ &           $-0.01\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ &        $+0.002\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.02}$ &        $-0.009\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.02}$ &       $+0.006\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.009}$ \\
-QCD                                       &           $-0.04\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.2}$ &          $-0.12\substack{+0.18 \\ -0.2}$ &           $-0.04\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ &       $+0.0009\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.02}$ &       $-0.01\substack{+0.022 \\ -0.029}$ &        $+0.001\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.01}$ \\
-Quantum Field Theory                      &           $+0.04\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.2}$ &         $+0.12\substack{+0.25 \\ -0.21}$ &           $+0.04\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.2}$ &        $-0.006\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.03}$ &       $+0.0001\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.03}$ &        $-0.002\substack{+0.01 \\ -0.02}$ \\
-AdS/CFT                                   &          $+0.005\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.2}$ &           $+0.08\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.2}$ &          $+0.009\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.2}$ &        $-0.007\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.03}$ &        $-0.001\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.03}$ &        $-0.003\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.02}$ \\
+\textbf{Intellectual capital (diversity)} & $\bm{+0.29}\substack{+0.043 \\ -0.044}$ & $\bm{+0.29}\substack{+0.041 \\ -0.041}$ & $\bm{+0.24}\substack{+0.043 \\ -0.044}$ & $\bm{+0.05}\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.04}$ & $\bm{+1.2}\substack{+0.47 \\ -0.47}$ & $\bm{+0.05}\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.04}$ \\
+\textbf{Social capital (diversity)} & $\bm{+0.09}\substack{+0.041 \\ -0.041}$ & $\bm{+0.07}\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.04}$ & $\bm{+0.06}\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.04}$ & $\bm{+0.28}\substack{+0.045 \\ -0.044}$ & $\bm{+0.85}\substack{+0.47 \\ -0.47}$ & $\bm{+0.23}\substack{+0.043 \\ -0.043}$ \\
+\textbf{Social capital (power)} & $\bm{-0.19}\substack{+0.042 \\ -0.042}$ & $\bm{-0.18}\substack{+0.042 \\ -0.042}$ & $\bm{-0.13}\substack{+0.044 \\ -0.044}$ & $\bm{-0.21}\substack{+0.043 \\ -0.043}$ & $\bm{-0.19}\substack{+0.041 \\ -0.042}$ & $\bm{-0.13}\substack{+0.044 \\ -0.044}$ \\
+\textbf{Stable affiliation} & $-0.05\substack{+0.089 \\ -0.089}$ & $-0.04\substack{+0.09 \\ -0.09}$ & $-0.04\substack{+0.09 \\ -0.09}$ & $-0.03\substack{+0.09 \\ -0.09}$ & $-0.02\substack{+0.09 \\ -0.09}$ & $-0.01\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.09}$ \\
+\hline Hadrons & $+0.02\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ & $-0.11\substack{+0.17 \\ -0.2}$ & $-0.008\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ & $+0.004\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.02}$ & $-0.008\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.03}$ & $+0.001\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.01}$ \\
+String theory \& supergravity & $\bm{+0.29}\substack{+0.14 \\ -0.14}$ & $\bm{+0.38}\substack{+0.18 \\ -0.17}$ & $\bm{+0.16}\substack{+0.13 \\ -0.12}$ & $\bm{+0.02}\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.02}$ & $\bm{+0.04}\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.02}$ & $+0.005\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.009}$ \\
+Perturbative methods & $+0.1\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.2}$ & $+0.03\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.2}$ & $+0.09\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.2}$ & $+0.01\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.02}$ & $+0.01\substack{+0.034 \\ -0.025}$ & $+0.009\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.01}$ \\
+Classical fields & $-0.14\substack{+0.28 \\ -0.46}$ & $-0.1\substack{+0.33 \\ -0.44}$ & $-0.09\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.4}$ & $-0.01\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.05}$ & $-0.009\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.05}$ & $-0.004\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.03}$ \\
+Collider physics & $\bm{-0.15}\substack{+0.15 \\ -0.16}$ & $\bm{-0.33}\substack{+0.18 \\ -0.18}$ & $\bm{-0.18}\substack{+0.15 \\ -0.15}$ & $-0.003\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.02}$ & $\bm{-0.02}\substack{+0.019 \\ -0.029}$ & $-0.003\substack{+0.01 \\ -0.01}$ \\
+Dynamics & $-0.04\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.3}$ & $-0.01\substack{+0.35 \\ -0.36}$ & $-0.02\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.3}$ & $+0.0009\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.03}$ & $+0.003\substack{+0.05 \\ -0.04}$ & $+0.001\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.02}$ \\
+Neutrinos \& flavour physics & $\bm{+0.25}\substack{+0.17 \\ -0.16}$ & $+0.17\substack{+0.19 \\ -0.18}$ & $\bm{+0.18}\substack{+0.16 \\ -0.15}$ & $\bm{+0.02}\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.02}$ & $+0.02\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.02}$ & $+0.008\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.01}$ \\
+Black holes & $+0.03\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.1}$ & $+0.16\substack{+0.21 \\ -0.19}$ & $+0.002\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ & $-0.008\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.03}$ & $+0.006\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.02}$ & $-0.007\substack{+0.01 \\ -0.02}$ \\
+Gauge theory \& Grand Unification & $-0.06\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.3}$ & $-0.08\substack{+0.29 \\ -0.35}$ & $-0.03\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.3}$ & $-0.003\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.03}$ & $-0.007\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.05}$ & $+0.0002\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.02}$ \\
+Dark matter & $-0.2\substack{+0.21 \\ -0.24}$ & $\bm{-0.3}\substack{+0.25 \\ -0.26}$ & $-0.19\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.24}$ & $-0.02\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.04}$ & $-0.02\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.04}$ & $-0.009\substack{+0.01 \\ -0.03}$ \\
+Thermodynamics & $+0.07\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.2}$ & $+0.19\substack{+0.39 \\ -0.29}$ & $+0.07\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.21}$ & $+0.006\substack{+0.04 \\ -0.03}$ & $+0.01\substack{+0.05 \\ -0.03}$ & $+0.004\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.02}$ \\
+Cosmology & $-0.008\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.2}$ & $+0.04\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.2}$ & $-0.03\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ & $-0.009\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.03}$ & $-0.003\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.03}$ & $-0.006\substack{+0.01 \\ -0.02}$ \\
+Electroweak sector & $-0.06\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ & $-0.17\substack{+0.17 \\ -0.18}$ & $-0.02\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ & $+0.002\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.02}$ & $-0.01\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.03}$ & $+0.005\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.01}$ \\
+QCD & $-0.02\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.2}$ & $-0.1\substack{+0.17 \\ -0.19}$ & $-0.02\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ & $+0.003\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.02}$ & $-0.008\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.03}$ & $+0.003\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.01}$ \\
+Quantum Field Theory & $+0.05\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.2}$ & $+0.13\substack{+0.25 \\ -0.2}$ & $+0.05\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.2}$ & $-0.006\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.03}$ & $+0.001\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.03}$ & $-0.002\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.02}$ \\
+AdS/CFT & $-0.005\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.2}$ & $+0.07\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.2}$ & $-0.003\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.2}$ & $-0.008\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.03}$ & $-0.002\substack{+0.03 \\ -0.03}$ & $-0.004\substack{+0.02 \\ -0.03}$ \\
 \bottomrule
 \end{tabular}\normalsize\renewcommand{\arraystretch}{1}
 \end{table}

+ 22 - 23
output/etm_20_pretrained/summary_entered_exited.tex

@@ -1,33 +1,32 @@
 \begin{table}[H]
-\centering
 \caption{Effect of each variable on (a) the probability of having entered a new research area and (b) the probability of having exited a research area, for each model. The reference model uses entropy as the diversity measure $D$ and the magnitude of intellectual capital as a measure of power $P$. Values indicate the mean posterior effect size and the 95\% credible interval. Significant effects are shown in bold.}
 \label{table:summary_entered_exited}
 \renewcommand{\arraystretch}{2}\fontsize{6}{7}\selectfont\begin{tabular}{lllllll}
 \toprule
 Dep. variable & \multicolumn{3}{c}{Entered a new research area} & \multicolumn{3}{c}{Exited a research area} \\
-Model &                              Reference &                    $D=\text{Stirling}$ &                   $P=\text{Brokerage}$ &                              Reference &                    $D=\text{Stirling}$ &                   $P=\text{Brokerage}$ \\
-Predictor                                 &                                        &                                        &                                        &                                        &                                        &                                        \\
+Model & Reference & $D=\text{Stirling}$ & $P=\text{Brokerage}$ & Reference & $D=\text{Stirling}$ & $P=\text{Brokerage}$ \\
+Predictor &  &  &  &  &  &  \\
 \midrule
-\textbf{Intellectual capital (diversity)} &  $\bm{+0.15}\substack{+0.11 \\ -0.11}$ &  $\bm{+0.14}\substack{+0.099 \\ -0.1}$ &  $\bm{+0.12}\substack{+0.11 \\ -0.11}$ &   $\bm{+1.1}\substack{+0.14 \\ -0.14}$ &  $\bm{+0.86}\substack{+0.12 \\ -0.12}$ &  $\bm{+0.96}\substack{+0.14 \\ -0.13}$ \\
-\textbf{Social capital (diversity)}       &     $\bm{+0.2}\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ &    $\bm{+0.16}\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ &    $\bm{+0.18}\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ &         $+0.06\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ &         $+0.04\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ &         $+0.01\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ \\
-\textbf{Social capital (power)}           &    $\bm{-0.12}\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ &    $\bm{-0.11}\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ &         $-0.07\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ &  $\bm{-0.31}\substack{+0.11 \\ -0.11}$ &  $\bm{-0.26}\substack{+0.11 \\ -0.11}$ &    $\bm{-0.18}\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ \\
-\textbf{Stable affiliation}               &       $-0.14\substack{+0.19 \\ -0.19}$ &       $-0.14\substack{+0.19 \\ -0.19}$ &        $-0.15\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.19}$ &       $-0.11\substack{+0.21 \\ -0.21}$ &         $-0.07\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.2}$ &       $-0.15\substack{+0.21 \\ -0.21}$ \\
-\hline Hadrons                                   &       $-0.11\substack{+0.31 \\ -0.36}$ &       $-0.21\substack{+0.33 \\ -0.39}$ &        $-0.13\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.36}$ &         $-0.04\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.3}$ &       $-0.27\substack{+0.39 \\ -0.45}$ &         $-0.06\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.3}$ \\
-String theory \& supergravity             &  $\bm{+0.44}\substack{+0.35 \\ -0.32}$ &  $\bm{+0.53}\substack{+0.36 \\ -0.35}$ &  $\bm{+0.36}\substack{+0.33 \\ -0.31}$ &  $\bm{+0.46}\substack{+0.36 \\ -0.34}$ &   $\bm{+0.9}\substack{+0.42 \\ -0.42}$ &       $+0.23\substack{+0.34 \\ -0.25}$ \\
-Perturbative methods                      &         $+0.05\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ &         $+0.03\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ &         $+0.06\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ &       $-0.13\substack{+0.33 \\ -0.46}$ &       $-0.33\substack{+0.47 \\ -0.57}$ &          $-0.1\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.4}$ \\
-Classical fields                          &        $+0.26\substack{+1.2 \\ -0.63}$ &         $+0.4\substack{+1.5 \\ -0.75}$ &        $+0.26\substack{+1.2 \\ -0.63}$ &        $-0.43\substack{+0.64 \\ -1.6}$ &        $-0.51\substack{+0.85 \\ -1.3}$ &        $-0.27\substack{+0.48 \\ -1.2}$ \\
-Collider physics                          &  $\bm{-0.35}\substack{+0.33 \\ -0.35}$ &  $\bm{-0.52}\substack{+0.34 \\ -0.35}$ &  $\bm{-0.37}\substack{+0.33 \\ -0.35}$ &       $+0.06\substack{+0.31 \\ -0.25}$ &        $-0.2\substack{+0.35 \\ -0.41}$ &       $+0.02\substack{+0.26 \\ -0.23}$ \\
-Dynamics                                  &        $-0.18\substack{+0.6 \\ -0.85}$ &       $-0.18\substack{+0.66 \\ -0.89}$ &       $-0.16\substack{+0.58 \\ -0.83}$ &         $-0.02\substack{+0.6 \\ -0.7}$ &        $+0.14\substack{+1.1 \\ -0.86}$ &        $-0.006\substack{+0.6 \\ -0.6}$ \\
-Neutrinos \& flavour physics              &       $+0.14\substack{+0.37 \\ -0.29}$ &          $+0.1\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.3}$ &       $+0.11\substack{+0.35 \\ -0.29}$ &       $-0.19\substack{+0.27 \\ -0.35}$ &       $-0.33\substack{+0.38 \\ -0.44}$ &       $-0.25\substack{+0.28 \\ -0.37}$ \\
-Black holes                               &         $-0.07\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.4}$ &        $+0.006\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ &         $-0.08\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.4}$ &       $+0.16\substack{+0.48 \\ -0.32}$ &  $\bm{+0.78}\substack{+0.59 \\ -0.56}$ &       $+0.12\substack{+0.44 \\ -0.28}$ \\
-Gauge theory \& Grand Unification         &        $+0.003\substack{+0.6 \\ -0.6}$ &        $+0.009\substack{+0.7 \\ -0.6}$ &         $+0.02\substack{+0.6 \\ -0.6}$ &       $-0.11\substack{+0.52 \\ -0.78}$ &        $-0.12\substack{+0.8 \\ -0.88}$ &         $-0.06\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.6}$ \\
-Dark matter                               &  $\bm{-0.65}\substack{+0.56 \\ -0.55}$ &  $\bm{-0.71}\substack{+0.56 \\ -0.57}$ &  $\bm{-0.64}\substack{+0.55 \\ -0.56}$ &         $+0.02\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ &        $-0.002\substack{+0.5 \\ -0.5}$ &         $+0.02\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.3}$ \\
-Thermodynamics                            &         $-0.07\substack{+0.6 \\ -0.7}$ &         $-0.04\substack{+0.6 \\ -0.6}$ &         $-0.05\substack{+0.6 \\ -0.6}$ &         $+0.05\substack{+0.7 \\ -0.6}$ &        $+0.35\substack{+1.2 \\ -0.77}$ &         $+0.04\substack{+0.6 \\ -0.5}$ \\
-Cosmology                                 &        $+0.004\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.3}$ &         $+0.06\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ &        $-0.004\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.3}$ &        $+0.15\substack{+0.5 \\ -0.33}$ &   $\bm{+0.56}\substack{+0.6 \\ -0.54}$ &        $+0.1\substack{+0.44 \\ -0.29}$ \\
-Electroweak sector                        &        $+0.1\substack{+0.33 \\ -0.28}$ &         $+0.06\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.3}$ &       $+0.12\substack{+0.35 \\ -0.29}$ &         $+0.05\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.3}$ &         $-0.03\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ &        $+0.1\substack{+0.35 \\ -0.24}$ \\
-QCD                                       &       $-0.07\substack{+0.31 \\ -0.35}$ &       $-0.12\substack{+0.33 \\ -0.38}$ &         $-0.07\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.4}$ &         $+0.02\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.3}$ &        $+0.008\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ &         $+0.03\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.3}$ \\
-Quantum Field Theory                      &        $+0.3\substack{+0.61 \\ -0.42}$ &       $+0.41\substack{+0.65 \\ -0.49}$ &       $+0.31\substack{+0.62 \\ -0.43}$ &         $-0.03\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ &       $+0.22\substack{+0.61 \\ -0.48}$ &         $-0.01\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ \\
-AdS/CFT                                   &       $+0.17\substack{+0.64 \\ -0.45}$ &        $+0.26\substack{+0.72 \\ -0.5}$ &       $+0.18\substack{+0.65 \\ -0.45}$ &         $-0.05\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.5}$ &       $+0.21\substack{+0.74 \\ -0.57}$ &         $-0.03\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.5}$ \\
+\textbf{Intellectual capital (diversity)} & $\bm{+0.15}\substack{+0.11 \\ -0.11}$ & $\bm{+0.14}\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ & $\bm{+0.12}\substack{+0.11 \\ -0.11}$ & $\bm{+1.1}\substack{+0.14 \\ -0.14}$ & $\bm{+0.88}\substack{+0.12 \\ -0.12}$ & $\bm{+1}\substack{+0.14 \\ -0.13}$ \\
+\textbf{Social capital (diversity)} & $\bm{+0.2}\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ & $\bm{+0.16}\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ & $\bm{+0.18}\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ & $+0.06\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ & $+0.04\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ & $+0.02\substack{+0.11 \\ -0.11}$ \\
+\textbf{Social capital (power)} & $\bm{-0.12}\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ & $\bm{-0.11}\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ & $-0.06\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ & $\bm{-0.27}\substack{+0.11 \\ -0.11}$ & $\bm{-0.22}\substack{+0.11 \\ -0.11}$ & $\bm{-0.16}\substack{+0.1 \\ -0.1}$ \\
+\textbf{Stable affiliation} & $-0.15\substack{+0.22 \\ -0.22}$ & $-0.14\substack{+0.22 \\ -0.22}$ & $-0.14\substack{+0.22 \\ -0.22}$ & $+0.07\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.2}$ & $+0.1\substack{+0.24 \\ -0.24}$ & $+0.09\substack{+0.2 \\ -0.2}$ \\
+\hline Hadrons & $-0.12\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.36}$ & $-0.21\substack{+0.33 \\ -0.39}$ & $-0.13\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.36}$ & $-0.03\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.3}$ & $-0.27\substack{+0.39 \\ -0.45}$ & $-0.05\substack{+0.25 \\ -0.3}$ \\
+String theory \& supergravity & $\bm{+0.44}\substack{+0.34 \\ -0.32}$ & $\bm{+0.53}\substack{+0.36 \\ -0.35}$ & $\bm{+0.36}\substack{+0.33 \\ -0.31}$ & $\bm{+0.43}\substack{+0.36 \\ -0.35}$ & $\bm{+0.89}\substack{+0.42 \\ -0.42}$ & $+0.23\substack{+0.35 \\ -0.25}$ \\
+Perturbative methods & $+0.05\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ & $+0.03\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ & $+0.06\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ & $-0.13\substack{+0.33 \\ -0.46}$ & $-0.35\substack{+0.48 \\ -0.57}$ & $-0.1\substack{+0.29 \\ -0.43}$ \\
+Classical fields & $+0.26\substack{+1.3 \\ -0.65}$ & $+0.39\substack{+1.5 \\ -0.75}$ & $+0.26\substack{+1.2 \\ -0.62}$ & $-0.4\substack{+0.61 \\ -1.5}$ & $-0.5\substack{+0.83 \\ -1.3}$ & $-0.26\substack{+0.47 \\ -1.3}$ \\
+Collider physics & $\bm{-0.35}\substack{+0.33 \\ -0.35}$ & $\bm{-0.52}\substack{+0.34 \\ -0.35}$ & $\bm{-0.37}\substack{+0.33 \\ -0.35}$ & $+0.08\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.2}$ & $-0.18\substack{+0.35 \\ -0.41}$ & $+0.05\substack{+0.28 \\ -0.22}$ \\
+Dynamics & $-0.18\substack{+0.6 \\ -0.86}$ & $-0.18\substack{+0.65 \\ -0.88}$ & $-0.16\substack{+0.59 \\ -0.84}$ & $-0.02\substack{+0.6 \\ -0.7}$ & $+0.14\substack{+1.1 \\ -0.86}$ & $-0.009\substack{+0.5 \\ -0.5}$ \\
+Neutrinos \& flavour physics & $+0.14\substack{+0.37 \\ -0.3}$ & $+0.1\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.3}$ & $+0.11\substack{+0.34 \\ -0.29}$ & $-0.18\substack{+0.27 \\ -0.35}$ & $-0.33\substack{+0.38 \\ -0.44}$ & $-0.22\substack{+0.26 \\ -0.36}$ \\
+Black holes & $-0.07\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.4}$ & $+0.005\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ & $-0.08\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.4}$ & $+0.13\substack{+0.46 \\ -0.31}$ & $\bm{+0.73}\substack{+0.59 \\ -0.56}$ & $+0.08\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.3}$ \\
+Gauge theory \& Grand Unification & $+0.003\substack{+0.6 \\ -0.6}$ & $+0.008\substack{+0.7 \\ -0.6}$ & $+0.02\substack{+0.63 \\ -0.58}$ & $-0.1\substack{+0.49 \\ -0.73}$ & $-0.11\substack{+0.78 \\ -0.86}$ & $-0.06\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.6}$ \\
+Dark matter & $\bm{-0.65}\substack{+0.55 \\ -0.56}$ & $\bm{-0.71}\substack{+0.56 \\ -0.56}$ & $\bm{-0.64}\substack{+0.55 \\ -0.56}$ & $+0.001\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ & $-0.04\substack{+0.5 \\ -0.5}$ & $-0.001\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.3}$ \\
+Thermodynamics & $-0.06\substack{+0.6 \\ -0.6}$ & $-0.04\substack{+0.6 \\ -0.6}$ & $-0.05\substack{+0.6 \\ -0.6}$ & $+0.04\substack{+0.7 \\ -0.6}$ & $+0.33\substack{+1.3 \\ -0.76}$ & $+0.04\substack{+0.6 \\ -0.5}$ \\
+Cosmology & $+0.003\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.3}$ & $+0.06\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ & $-0.003\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ & $+0.15\substack{+0.49 \\ -0.32}$ & $\bm{+0.56}\substack{+0.61 \\ -0.55}$ & $+0.1\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.3}$ \\
+Electroweak sector & $+0.1\substack{+0.33 \\ -0.28}$ & $+0.06\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.3}$ & $+0.12\substack{+0.35 \\ -0.29}$ & $+0.03\substack{+0.29 \\ -0.25}$ & $-0.05\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ & $+0.07\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.2}$ \\
+QCD & $-0.07\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.3}$ & $-0.12\substack{+0.33 \\ -0.38}$ & $-0.06\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.3}$ & $+0.05\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.3}$ & $+0.04\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ & $+0.05\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.3}$ \\
+Quantum Field Theory & $+0.3\substack{+0.61 \\ -0.43}$ & $+0.41\substack{+0.65 \\ -0.49}$ & $+0.31\substack{+0.61 \\ -0.42}$ & $-0.03\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.4}$ & $+0.23\substack{+0.61 \\ -0.48}$ & $-0.01\substack{+0.3 \\ -0.4}$ \\
+AdS/CFT & $+0.17\substack{+0.66 \\ -0.46}$ & $+0.26\substack{+0.73 \\ -0.5}$ & $+0.17\substack{+0.65 \\ -0.45}$ & $-0.07\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.5}$ & $+0.18\substack{+0.73 \\ -0.56}$ & $-0.05\substack{+0.4 \\ -0.5}$ \\
 \bottomrule
 \end{tabular}\normalsize\renewcommand{\arraystretch}{1}
 \end{table}

+ 95 - 45
plots/ei_sankey.py

@@ -2,7 +2,8 @@ import numpy as np
 import pandas as pd
 
 import plotly.graph_objects as go
-import plotly.io as pio   
+import plotly.io as pio
+
 pio.kaleido.scope.mathjax = None
 
 import seaborn as sns
@@ -14,6 +15,9 @@ parser = argparse.ArgumentParser()
 parser.add_argument("--input")
 parser.add_argument("--suffix")
 parser.add_argument("--compact", action="store_true", default=False)
+parser.add_argument("--transparent", action="store_true", default=False)
+parser.add_argument("--highlight-in", default=list(), nargs="+")
+parser.add_argument("--highlight-out", default=list(), nargs="+")
 args = parser.parse_args()
 
 samples = np.load(opj(args.input, f"ei_samples_{args.suffix}.npz"))
@@ -34,20 +38,39 @@ print(colors)
 total_incoming = samples["counts"].mean(axis=0).sum(axis=1)
 total_outcoming = samples["counts"].mean(axis=0).sum(axis=0)
 
-incoming_labels = [f"{topics[i]} ({100*total_incoming[i]:.0f}%)" for i in range(n_topics)]
-outcoming_labels = [f"{topics[i]} ({100*total_outcoming[i]:.0f}%)" for i in range(n_topics)]
+incoming_labels = [
+    f"{topics[i]} ({100*total_incoming[i]:.0f}%)" for i in range(n_topics)
+]
+outcoming_labels = [
+    f"{topics[i]} ({100*total_outcoming[i]:.0f}%)" for i in range(n_topics)
+]
 
 for i in range(n_topics):
     for j in range(n_topics):
         v = samples["counts"][:, i, j].mean()
 
-        x = samples["counts"].mean(axis=0)[i,:].sum()
-        y = samples["counts"].mean(axis=0)[:,j].sum()
+        x = samples["counts"].mean(axis=0)[i, :].sum()
+        y = samples["counts"].mean(axis=0)[:, j].sum()
 
         value.append(v)
         source.append(i)
         target.append(j + n_topics)
-        color.append("rgba(100,100,100,0.2)" if v >= x*y else "rgba(200,200,200,0.02)")
+
+        highlight = (
+            (len(args.highlight_in) > 0 and topics[i] in args.highlight_in)
+            or (len(args.highlight_out) > 0 and topics[j] in args.highlight_out)
+            or (
+                (not args.transparent)
+                and (len(args.highlight_in + args.highlight_out) == 0)
+            )
+        ) and (v >= x * y)
+
+        # print(topics[i], topics[j])
+        # print((len(args.highlight_in) > 0 and topics[i] in args.highlight_in))
+        # print((len(args.highlight_out) > 0 and topics[j] in args.highlight_out))
+        # print((len(args.highlight_in + args.highlight_out) == 0))
+
+        color.append("rgba(100,100,100,0.3)" if highlight else "rgba(200,200,200,0.02)")
 
 fig = go.Figure(
     data=[
@@ -75,53 +98,80 @@ fig.update_layout(
     width=650 if args.compact else 800,
     height=600,
 )
-#fig.show()
-fig.write_image(opj(args.input, f"sankey_control_{args.suffix}{'_compact' if args.compact else ''}.pdf"), width=650 if args.compact else 800, height=600)
-
-transfers = pd.DataFrame([
-    {
-        "from": topics[i],
-        "to": topics[j],
-        "magnitude": 100*samples["counts"].mean(axis=0)[i,j],
-        "ratio": samples["counts"].mean(axis=0)[i,j]/samples["counts"].mean(axis=0)[i,:].sum()
-    }
-    for i in range(n_topics)
-    for j in range(n_topics)
-])
-
-
-latex = transfers[transfers["from"]!=transfers["to"]].sort_values("magnitude", ascending=False).head(10).to_latex(
-    columns=["from", "to", "magnitude"],
-    header=["Origin research area", "Target research area", "Magnitude"],
-    index=False,    
-    multirow=True,
-    multicolumn=True,
-    column_format='b{0.4\\textwidth}|b{0.4\\textwidth}|c',
-    escape=False,
-    float_format=lambda x: f"{x:.2f}",
-    caption="Largest transfers across research areas.",
-    label="table:largest_transfers"
+# fig.show()
+
+highlights = f"{'_'.join(args.highlight_in)}{'_'.join(args.highlight_out)}".replace(
+    "/", "_"
+).replace("&", "_").replace(" ", "").lower()
+if len(highlights):
+    highlights = f"_{highlights}"
+
+fig.write_image(
+    opj(
+        args.input,
+        f"sankey_control_{args.suffix}{'_compact' if args.compact else ''}{'_transparent' if args.transparent else ''}{highlights}.pdf",
+    ),
+    width=650 if args.compact else 800,
+    height=600,
+)
+
+transfers = pd.DataFrame(
+    [
+        {
+            "from": topics[i],
+            "to": topics[j],
+            "magnitude": 100 * samples["counts"].mean(axis=0)[i, j],
+            "ratio": samples["counts"].mean(axis=0)[i, j]
+            / samples["counts"].mean(axis=0)[i, :].sum(),
+        }
+        for i in range(n_topics)
+        for j in range(n_topics)
+    ]
+)
+
+
+latex = (
+    transfers[transfers["from"] != transfers["to"]]
+    .sort_values("magnitude", ascending=False)
+    .head(10)
+    .to_latex(
+        columns=["from", "to", "magnitude"],
+        header=["Origin research area", "Target research area", "Magnitude"],
+        index=False,
+        multirow=True,
+        multicolumn=True,
+        column_format="b{0.4\\textwidth}|b{0.4\\textwidth}|c",
+        escape=False,
+        float_format=lambda x: f"{x:.2f}",
+        caption="Largest transfers across research areas.",
+        label="table:largest_transfers",
+    )
 )
 
-latex = latex.replace('\\\\\n', '\\\\ \\hline\n')
+latex = latex.replace("\\\\\n", "\\\\ \\hline\n")
 
 with open(opj(args.input, "largest_transfers.tex"), "w+") as fp:
     fp.write(latex)
 
-latex = transfers[transfers["from"]==transfers["to"]].sort_values("ratio", ascending=False).head(10).to_latex(
-    columns=["from", "ratio"],
-    header=["Research area", "Conservatism"],
-    index=False,    
-    multirow=True,
-    multicolumn=True,
-    column_format='b{0.4\\textwidth}|b{0.4\\textwidth}|c',
-    escape=False,
-    float_format=lambda x: f"{x:.2f}",
-    caption="Most conservative research areas.",
-    label="table:most_conservative"
+latex = (
+    transfers[transfers["from"] == transfers["to"]]
+    .sort_values("ratio", ascending=False)
+    .head(10)
+    .to_latex(
+        columns=["from", "ratio"],
+        header=["Research area", "Conservatism"],
+        index=False,
+        multirow=True,
+        multicolumn=True,
+        column_format="b{0.4\\textwidth}|b{0.4\\textwidth}|c",
+        escape=False,
+        float_format=lambda x: f"{x:.2f}",
+        caption="Most conservative research areas.",
+        label="table:most_conservative",
+    )
 )
 
-latex = latex.replace('\\\\\n', '\\\\ \\hline\n')
+latex = latex.replace("\\\\\n", "\\\\ \\hline\n")
 
 with open(opj(args.input, "most_conservative.tex"), "w+") as fp:
     fp.write(latex)